Dispute Dissolve Committees as an Alternative Method to Judiciary in Resolving Insurance Disputes
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.33977/0507-000-066-001Keywords:
Dispute resolution committee, insurance, judiciaryAbstract
Objectives: The research aims to study the reasons that prompted the Palestinian legislator to adopt resorting to the Dispute Resolution Committee, and the purpose of the existence of this committee as an alternative to resorting to the regular judiciary.
Methods: The researcher used the analytical foundational approach, and used the comparative analytical approach in studying the legal systems.
Results: The research reached several results as follows: the need for alternative mechanisms to resolve insurance disputes in Palestine. The position of the legislation under the study varied regarding the formation of the committee, as some legislations considered it a judicial committee, while there are countries that considered it an administrative committee. The research showed the existence of some gaps in the Palestinian insurance draft law in organizing insurance dispute resolution committees.
Conclusions: The research concludes with a set of recommendations, are: approving the draft Palestinian insurance law, the draft law should specify a maximum timeframe for resolving insurance disputes, and decisions made by the committees should be binding on all parties involved. Additionally, the research recommends explicitly prohibiting conflicts of interest in the operation of these committees.
References
المصادر والمراجع باللغة العربية
- الأمانة العامة للجان الفصل في المنازعات والمخالفات التأمينية، 2022، مدونة السوابق القضائية التأمينية للجنة الاستئنافية للفصل في المنازعات والمخالفات التأمينية الصادرة لعام 1444 هجرية، الطبعة الأولى.
- الأمانة العامة للجان الفصل في المنازعات والمخالفات التأمينية، الموقع الإلكتروني:
- البطي، طلال. إجراءات عمل لجنة فض المنازعات التأمينية في السعودية، مقالة منشورة على الموقع الإلكتروني:
- الخريجي، عبد العزيز بن عبد الله. (2016) ورقة عمل بعنوان: الترافع أمام لجنة الفصل في المنازعات والمخالفات التأمينية، مقدمة في الملتقى الثاني السنوي للحقوقيين.
- خيرة، بلخوجة. عواد، بلعبدون. (2019) مصير شرط التحكيم التعسفي في عقد الإذعان عامة وعقد التأمين نموذجاً، كلية الحقوق والعلوم السياسية، جامعة عبد الحميد ابن باديس مستغانم، مجلد أبحاث، 4 (2).
- السنهوري، عبد الرزاق. (1964) الوسيط في شرح القانون المدني، الجزء السابع، المجلد الثاني، عقود الغرر، عقود المقامرة والرهان والمرتب مدى الحياة وعقد التأمين، بيروت، لبنان، دار إحياء التراث العربي.
- الشوفي، رنا. (2024) التعامل مع النزاعات التأمين: وكيفية الطعن على قرارات لجنة تسوية النزاعات التأمينية في الإمارات العربية المتحدة.
- عبد الكريم، مصطفى. نسيم، حامد بابا. (2022) حماية المستهلك كطرف ضعيف في العقد من الشروط التعسفية: شرط التحكيم في عقد التأمين نموذجاً، جامعة محمد بن أحمد وهران، مجلة الإدارة والتنمية للبحوث والدراسات، 11 (2).
- العيسى، عبد الحنان محمد. (2017) الوسائل البديلة لتسوية المنازعات. مجلة الاقتصاد الإسلامي العالمية، 57.
- فياض، فاروق. (2019) اعتماد هيئة التأمين الإماراتية نظام لجان تسوية وحل المنازعات التأمينية بحق شركات التأمين في الإمارات، منشورة على الموقع الإلكتروني: اعتماد لجان تسوية وحل المنازعات التأمينية في الدولة | صحيفة الخليج (alkhaleej.ae)
- مركز الصلح في المنازعات التأمينية في المملكة العربية السعودية، (2020) التقرير السنوي الثاني.
- مركز الصلح في المنازعات التأمينية في المملكة العربية السعودية، (2021) التقرير السنوي الثالث.
- مركز الصلح في المنازعات التأمينية في المملكة العربية السعودية، (2022) التقرير السنوي الرابع.
- الموقع الإلكتروني لقناة الجزيرة: https:// www.al-jazirah.com/ 2014/ 20140708/ ec8.htm.
- الموقع الإلكتروني للهيئة العامة للرقابة المالية المصرية.
References:
- Abdel Karim, Mustafa. Naseem, Hamid Baba. (2022) Protecting the consumer as a weak party in the contract from arbitrary terms: the arbitration clause in the insurance contract as a model, (In Arabic) University of Muhammad bin Ahmed Oran, Journal of Management and Development for Research and Studies, Volume 11, Issue 2.
- Al Jazirah Channel website: https:// www.al-jazirah.com/ 2014/ 20140708/ ec8.htm.
- Al-Butti, Talal. Work procedures of the Insurance Dispute Resolution Committee in Saudi Arabia, (In Arabic), an article published on the website:
- Al-Issa, Abdul Hanan Muhammad. (2017) Alternative Dispute Resolution. (In Arabic) International Islamic Economics Journal, No. 57.
- Al-Khereiji, Abdul Aziz bin Abdullah. (2016) A working paper entitled: Pleading before the Committee for Resolution of Insurance Disputes and Violations, (In Arabic) presented at the Second Annual Forum for Jurists.
- Al-Sanhouri, Abdul Razzaq. (1964) Al-Wasit fi Sharh Al-Law Al-Civil, (In Arabic) Part Seven, Volume Two, Gharar Contracts, Gambling and Betting Contracts, Lifetime Salary and Insurance Contracts, Beirut, Lebanon, Arab Heritage Revival House.
- Alsheha, Saleh, (2020) The Current System of Resolving Insurance Disputes in Saudi Arabia: Its Weaknesses and Ways of Developing It. Maurer School of Law: Indiana University, Maurer Theses and Dissertations.
- Al-Shoufi, Rana. (2024) Dealing with insurance disputes: How to appeal the decisions of the Insurance Dispute Settlement Committee in the United Arab Emirates, (In Arabic), published on the following website:
- Center for Reconciliation in Insurance Disputes in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, (In Arabic), (2020) Second Annual Report.
- Center for Reconciliation in Insurance Disputes in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, (In Arabic), (2021) Third Annual Report.
- Center for Reconciliation in Insurance Disputes in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, (In Arabic), (2022) Fourth Annual Report.
- Egyptian Financial Supervision Authority, website
- Fayyad, Farouk. (2019) Approval by the Emirates Insurance Authority of the system of committees for settling and resolving insurance disputes against insurance companies in the Emirates, (In Arabic) published on the website: Approval of committees for settling and resolving insurance disputes in the country | Al Khaleej newspaper (alkhaleej.ae)
- General Secretariat of Committees for Resolution of Insurance Disputes and Violations, (In Arabic) website:
- General Secretariat of the Committees for Settlement of Insurance Disputes and Violations, 2022, (In Arabic) Code of Insurance Case Law of the Appeals Committee for the Settlement of Insurance Disputes and Violations issued for the year 1444 AH, first edition.
https:// dubailawyers.ae/%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AA%D8%B9%D8%A7%D9%85%D9%84-%D9%85%D8%B9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%86%D8%B2%D8%A7%D8%B9%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AA%D8%A3%D9%85%D9%8A%D9%86%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D9%88%D9%83%D9%8A%D9%81%D9%8A%D8%A9/
https:// www.al-jazirah.com/ 2014/ 20140708/ ec8.htm.
https:// www.idc.gov.sa/ ar-sa/ Aboutus/ PreliminaryCommittees/ Pages/ default.aspx.
- Jing, Z. (2018). A New Insurance Dispute Resolution Mechanism: The Linked Litigation- Mediation Scheme in China. Journal of Business Law, Bangor University, UK.
- Khaira, Belkhoja. Awad, Belabdoun. (2019) The fate of the arbitrary arbitration clause in the adhesion contract in general and the insurance contract as a model, (In Arabic) Faculty of Law and Political Science, Abdelhamid Ibn Badis Mostaganem University, Research Volume, Volume Four, Issue Two.
- Robert H. Jerry II, 2015 Dispute Resolution, Insurance, and Points of Convergence, University of Missouri School of Law, Journal of Dispute Resolution, Issue 2, Article 3.
- Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan, Press Release, May 14, 2015, www.secp.gov.pk
- Working Secretariat of the Committees for Settlement of Insurance Disputes and Violations, 2022, Code of Insurance Case Law of the Appeals Committee for the Settlement of Insurance Disputes and Violations issued for the year 1444 AH, (In Arabic) first edition.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Journal of Al-Quds Open University for Humanities and Social Studies

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
- The editorial board confirms its commitment to the intellectual property rights
- Researchers also have to commit to the intellectual property rights.
- The research copyrights and publication are owned by the Journal once the researcher is notified about the approval of the paper. The scientific materials published or approved for publishing in the Journal should not be republished unless a written acknowledgment is obtained by the Deanship of Scientific Research.
- Research papers should not be published or republished unless a written acknowledgement is obtained from the Deanship of Scientific Research.
- The researcher has the right to accredit the research to himself, and to place his name on all the copies, editions and volumes published.
- The author has the right to request the accreditation of the published papers to himself.











_2.png)
_.png)
_2.png)
_1.png)
_.png)
